⚡ ACTION CENTER

ManiInfo Global

New Zealand’s New Tax Guidance on Open-Loop Gift Cards vs FBT: What Employers and Businesses Must Know

As of September 15, 2025, Inland Revenue has released updated guidance on how open-loop gift cards are treated for tax purposes in New Zealand. This update clarifies whether these prepaid cards fall under Fringe Benefit Tax (FBT) or Pay-As-You-Earn (PAYE), a distinction with major financial implications for employers. In this article, we explain the new rules, what they mean for businesses, and how you can stay compliant under the latest guidance.

This guide is especially relevant for employers, accountants, and HR managers who regularly provide non-cash benefits to staff. With Inland Revenue now setting out a clearer stance, businesses need to adapt policies quickly. Let’s break down the changes, real examples, and strategic insights to help you navigate this tax update with confidence.

Understanding New Zealand’s Tax Update on Open-Loop Cards

Background: Why Open-Loop Cards Are Under Scrutiny

Open-loop gift cards, unlike store-specific vouchers, can be used across multiple retailers. Because of this flexibility, Inland Revenue has been debating whether they should be taxed as cash equivalents. Historically, many employers treated them under FBT rules, similar to non-cash benefits like gym memberships or meal vouchers. However, Inland Revenue’s latest operational position (OP 25/02) makes it clear that open-loop cards may instead be subject to PAYE income tax.

This shift reflects global trends in tax policy, where regulators aim to close loopholes around cash-like incentives. For employers, the risk of misclassification has always been high. By aligning with the new stance, companies can reduce audit risks and unexpected tax liabilities.

  • Open-loop = usable widely, considered closer to “cash”.
  • Closed-loop = tied to one retailer, more like a traditional voucher.
  • FBT vs PAYE distinction is crucial for compliance.

Experience from businesses shows that many SMEs in Auckland and Wellington struggled with consistent treatment in past audits. This new guidance aims to create certainty and fairness.

Key Features of the September 2025 Guidance

The Inland Revenue document outlines specific criteria for when open-loop cards fall under PAYE obligations rather than FBT. In short:

  1. If the card is widely accepted and functions like cash, treat it as PAYE.
  2. If it is limited to a single merchant, it may still qualify for FBT.
  3. Employers must reassess all historical distributions of gift cards to ensure accuracy.

Notably, Inland Revenue has provided transitional relief for prior years, but only where genuine uncertainty existed. This means penalties may be waived if employers voluntarily correct misclassified benefits before March 2026.

According to Inland Revenue, the move is part of a broader effort to streamline benefit taxation and align with digital payment realities.

Practical Impact for Employers

For employers, this change means adjusting payroll systems and HR policies immediately. Since PAYE tax is withheld at source, businesses must ensure their payroll provider can process open-loop card benefits correctly. Otherwise, employees may be under- or over-taxed, leading to compliance risks.

Practical steps employers can take:

  • Audit recent benefit distributions (past 24 months).
  • Consult payroll software providers for system updates.
  • Communicate changes to employees receiving these cards.
  • Document all tax treatment decisions for audit protection.

Employers interviewed by Deloitte NZ noted that most staff prefer open-loop cards for their flexibility, but businesses now face higher compliance costs. Balancing staff satisfaction with regulatory risk will be a key leadership decision.

💡 How Does This Affect Small and Medium Enterprises?

SMEs often use gift cards as low-cost incentives for staff. With this shift, SMEs may need to reconsider whether the administrative burden outweighs the motivational benefits. Payroll teams will need more resources, and smaller firms without in-house tax advisors may struggle. Professional accountants suggest that SMEs explore alternative recognition programs that remain under FBT to simplify reporting.

Case Study: A Christchurch café chain reported that its holiday gift card scheme now costs an additional NZD 8,000 per year due to PAYE obligations. This illustrates the real-world impact on small businesses.

Compliance Strategies: Staying Ahead of Inland Revenue

Businesses can mitigate risk by setting up internal compliance frameworks. This includes:

  • Updating staff handbooks with the new PAYE treatment of open-loop cards.
  • Setting a maximum threshold for card values to reduce exposure.
  • Engaging with professional tax advisors for quarterly compliance checks.
  • Leveraging Inland Revenue’s voluntary disclosure program if past errors are identified.

These steps not only prevent penalties but also demonstrate good governance, which is valuable for investors and shareholders. The Gilligan Sheppard Tax Updates also recommend proactive engagement to avoid disputes.

Insights for Employees and HR Managers

For employees, the update could mean slightly reduced take-home value if PAYE deductions apply. HR managers must ensure transparent communication, as sudden changes in net benefit could harm employee trust. Best practice is to clearly explain why the change is happening and how it keeps both staff and the company compliant.

Employee insight: One Wellington IT firm reported that staff initially resisted the shift but accepted it after HR held workshops explaining the Inland Revenue position. This shows that transparency reduces dissatisfaction.

Broader Implications for New Zealand’s Tax Landscape

This guidance signals a trend towards treating digital and prepaid financial products as cash equivalents. Similar debates exist globally regarding crypto incentives and digital wallets. For New Zealand, this could foreshadow tighter regulation around alternative payment methods. Businesses should anticipate more PAYE-based treatments in the coming years, making FBT less relevant for cash-like items.

Investors and financial analysts see this as a sign of Inland Revenue modernising its framework, ensuring tax integrity while addressing the growth of fintech products.

Summary and Key Takeaways

  • Open-loop gift cards are now likely subject to PAYE, not FBT.
  • Employers must update payroll and HR systems immediately.
  • SMEs may face higher compliance costs but can adapt through planning.
  • Employees should expect transparent communication about net benefit changes.
  • This marks a broader shift towards taxing digital and cash-equivalent benefits.

For Verified information, visit Inland Revenue NZ and consult professional advisors for tailored guidance.

FAQ: Open-Loop Cards and FBT in New Zealand

What are open-loop gift cards in New Zealand?

They are prepaid cards that can be used at multiple retailers, unlike closed-loop cards restricted to one store. Inland Revenue now treats them as closer to cash equivalents.

Are open-loop cards subject to FBT or PAYE?

According to the September 2025 guidance, they are generally subject to PAYE withholding rather than FBT, because of their cash-like nature.

What should employers do if they misclassified cards in the past?

Inland Revenue offers transitional relief. Employers can voluntarily disclose errors, and penalties may be waived if corrected before March 2026.

How will this impact SMEs in New Zealand?

SMEs may face higher compliance costs due to payroll adjustments. Some are reconsidering whether to continue offering open-loop cards as staff incentives.

Where can I find Verified updates?

Check Inland Revenue’s Verified website and consult professional tax advisors for tailored business advice.

Leave a Comment

James Mani
Senior Policy Analyst, ManiInfo Global
James Mani specializes in tracking and analyzing the latest official public policies and government announcements. At ManiInfo Global, he focuses on delivering accurate, fact-based insights to help readers navigate complex financial, tax, and welfare regulations safely and clearly.
✓ Fact-Based Analysis ✓ Official Data Sourced